Difference between revisions of "Utilisateur:Ptilu/Tmp trad ridiculous goingon"

From La Quadrature du Net
Jump to navigationJump to search
(A ridiculous and outrageous law,)
Line 6: Line 6:
 
== A ridiculous and outrageous law, ==
 
== A ridiculous and outrageous law, ==
  
The bill establishing the "graduated response" against the internauts, a kind of discriminatory administrative justice, was placed on the agenda of the Senate for 29 October. While many bills were delayed because of Economic crisis, the cavalierly review seems totally inconsistent ..
+
The bill establishing the "graduated response" against the internauts, a kind of discriminatory administrative justice, was placed on the agenda of the Senate for 29 October. While many bills were delayed because of Economic crisis, maintaining this cavalierly review seems totally inconsistent ..
  
 
"This legislation is ridiculous and outrageous. "Said Jérémie Zimmermann, co-founder of La Quadrature du Net (Squaring the Net) ," It is totally technically and economically inefficient. It does not bring a penny to the authors and, especially in times of crisis, will not alter sales records and files. It must be anbandoned. "
 
"This legislation is ridiculous and outrageous. "Said Jérémie Zimmermann, co-founder of La Quadrature du Net (Squaring the Net) ," It is totally technically and economically inefficient. It does not bring a penny to the authors and, especially in times of crisis, will not alter sales records and files. It must be anbandoned. "
 
  
 
== ... contrary to European law, ==
 
== ... contrary to European law, ==

Revision as of 12:08, 20 October 2008

Graduated response : the ridiculous going on

The graduated response against internauts that will probably be discussed in the Senate on October 29th is already dead-born. Both technically and economically inefficient, disparaged by everyone because it violates the fundamental freedoms and it is contrary to European law, the text will end up in the dustbin of the Republic, like its predecessor DADVSI law. La Quadrature du Net (Squaring the Net) is asking the European Commission to confirm the decision of 88% of MEPs arguing that this text is incompatible with Community law and calls the French senators to reject it overwhelmingly.

A ridiculous and outrageous law,

The bill establishing the "graduated response" against the internauts, a kind of discriminatory administrative justice, was placed on the agenda of the Senate for 29 October. While many bills were delayed because of Economic crisis, maintaining this cavalierly review seems totally inconsistent ..

"This legislation is ridiculous and outrageous. "Said Jérémie Zimmermann, co-founder of La Quadrature du Net (Squaring the Net) ," It is totally technically and economically inefficient. It does not bring a penny to the authors and, especially in times of crisis, will not alter sales records and files. It must be anbandoned. "

... contrary to European law,

On last 24 September, 88% of MEPs voted an amendement 2 recalling the key role of judiciary authority as the guardian of fundamental freedoms of internauts 3. Nicolas Sarkozy recognize 4 himself that this amendment prevented categorically the implementation of the french Bill .

La Quadrature du Net encourages the European Commission, which has already pronounced in favor of the maitain of this fundamental principle of european law 5, to confirm its position. It must order to France, in its opinion due on October 23, to postpone the consideration of the law "Création et Internet ».


... it must be abandoned.

In other respects, La Quadrature du Net encouraged the senators, on the assumption that the text would be still overhasty planned on the agenda, to reject it massively. "This legislation costly botched and unworkable is unworthy of a modern democracy. Internauts will be particularly vigilant to the position and votes of Socialists senators. Some of them 6, who might have similar interests to those of the entertainment industries, have already announced they would accompany the presidential majority in what looks like a minefield of legislation. "Says Gérald Sédrati-Dinet, an analyst for La Quadrature du Net.