Telecoms Package Plenary Voting List

From La Quadrature du Net
Revision as of 21:10, 18 September 2008 by Neurone2 (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigationJump to search
Amending Amendended Topic Am. # Source Advice Comment
Trautmann Art. 1.8.e Framework Art. 8.4.g Net Neutrality 61 ITRE -- notion of "lawful" threatens net neutrality and is out-of-scope of Telecoms Package
Trautmann Art. 1.8.e Framework Art. 8.4.g Net Neutrality 130=142 IND/DEM, GUE/NGL ++ delete "lawful"
Trautmann Art. 1.8.e Framework Art. 8.4.ga Net Neutrality 131=143 IND/DEM, GUE/NGL ++ restrictions can only be dicated by force majeure, network integrity and security or criminal law imposed for reasons of public policy, public security or public morality
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea Framework Art. 8.4.ga Net Neutrality 132 Toubon, Hieronymi and al. -- opens door to 3-strikes approach
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea Framework Art. 8.4.ga Net Neutrality 137 PPE-DE -- opens door to 3-strikes approach
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea Framework Art. 8.4.ga Net Neutrality 138 Bono, Cohn-Bendit, Roithová and al. +++ restore judicial authority
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea Framework Art. 8.4.g Net Neutrality 138 Verts/ALE ++ retrictions subject to criminal law imposed for reasons of public policy, public security or public morality
Trautmann Art. 1.9 Framework Art. 9 Net Neutrality 64 ITRE -- "cultural and media policy objectives" opens door to filtering, stick to "promotion of cultural and linguistic diversity"
Trautmann Art. 2.6a Authorisation Art. 9.1 Net Neutrality 98 ITRE -- restrictions on access to services and applications" endangers net neutrality
Trautmann Art. 2.8 Authorisation Art. 12 Net Neutrality 100 ITRE -- obligations about "intellectual property rights" (paragraph 2, point e) is out-of-scope
Trautmann Art. 2.8.ba Authorisation Art. 12.2 Net Neutrality 141 Verts/ALE ++ delete obligations about "intellectual property rights"
Trautmann Annex I.2.g Access Annex I.A.19 Net Neutrality 120 ITRE ++ deletion is good, since relation with EUCD and IPRED is out-of-scope
Trautmann Chap. VI Art 55a General Provisions Internet Filtering 133 GUE/NGL ++ prevents Internet filtering


Amending Amendended Topic Am. # Source Advice Comment
Harbour Rec. 14 Net Neutrality 11 IMCO -- notion of "lawful" threatens net neutrality and is out-of-scope of Telecoms Package
Harbour Rec. 14a Net Neutrality 12 IMCO -- allows restriction to particular types of content or applications
Harbour Rec. 14c Net Neutrality 14 IMCO -- allows DRM imposed by NRA approved by Commission
Harbour Rec. 26b Security 27 IMCO/LIBE 0 implementing measures regarding security of personal data
Harbour Rec. 26c Privacy 28 IMCO/LIBE 0 reference to Data Protection Directive
Harbour Rec. 28a Privacy 30 IMCO/LIBE -- IP address as personal data
Harbour Rec. 29 Security 33 IMCO/LIBE - Breaches of security notified to NRA not to users
Harbour Rec. 30a Privacy 34 IMCO/LIBE 0 Relation between ePrivacy & Data Protection Directives and IPRED
Harbour Rec. 30b Privacy 35 IMCO/LIBE - "fundamental rights" include protection of Imaginary Property Rights (IPR)