Telecoms Package Plenary Voting List : Différence entre versions
De La Quadrature du Net
Aller à la navigationAller à la recherchem (Protected "Telecoms Package Plenary Voting List" [edit=autoconfirmed:move=autoconfirmed]) |
|||
Ligne 2 : | Ligne 2 : | ||
! Amending !! Amendended !! Topic !! Am. # !! Source !! Advice !! Comment | ! Amending !! Amendended !! Topic !! Am. # !! Source !! Advice !! Comment | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | | Trautmann Art. 1.8. | + | | Trautmann Art. 1.8.e || Framework Art. 8.4.g || Net Neutrality || 61 || ITRE || -- || notion of "lawful" threatens net neutrality and is out-of-scope of Telecoms Package |
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 1.8.e || Framework Art. 8.4.g || Net Neutrality || 130=142 || IND/DEM, GUE/NGL || ++ || delete "lawful" | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 1.8.e || Framework Art. 8.4.ga || Net Neutrality || 131=143 || IND/DEM, GUE/NGL || ++ || restrictions can only be dicated by force majeure, network integrity and security or criminal law imposed for reasons of public policy, public security or public morality | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea || Framework Art. 8.4.ga || Net Neutrality || 132 || Toubon, Hieronymi and al. || -- || opens door to 3-strikes approach | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea || Framework Art. 8.4.ga || Net Neutrality || 137 || PPE-DE || -- || opens door to 3-strikes approach | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea || Framework Art. 8.4.ga || Net Neutrality || 138 || Bono, Cohn-Bendit, Roithová and al. || +++ || restore judicial authority | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea || Framework Art. 8.4.g || Net Neutrality || 138 || Verts/ALE || ++ || retrictions subject to criminal law imposed for reasons of public policy, public security or public morality | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Trautmann Art. 1.9 || Framework Art. 9 || Net Neutrality || 64 || ITRE || -- || "cultural and media policy objectives" opens door to filtering, stick to "promotion of cultural and linguistic diversity" | | Trautmann Art. 1.9 || Framework Art. 9 || Net Neutrality || 64 || ITRE || -- || "cultural and media policy objectives" opens door to filtering, stick to "promotion of cultural and linguistic diversity" | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 2.6a || Authorisation Art. 9.1 || Net Neutrality || 98 || ITRE || -- || restrictions on access to services and applications" endangers net neutrality | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 2.8 || Authorisation Art. 12 || Net Neutrality || 100 || ITRE || -- || obligations about "intellectual property rights" (paragraph 2, point e) is out-of-scope | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Art. 2.8.ba || Authorisation Art. 12.2 || Net Neutrality || 141 || Verts/ALE || ++ || delete obligations about "intellectual property rights" | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Annex I.2.g || Access Annex I.A.19 || Net Neutrality || 120 || ITRE || ++ || deletion is good, since relation with EUCD and IPRED is out-of-scope | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | Trautmann Chap. VI Art 55a || General Provisions || Internet Filtering || 133 || GUE/NGL || ++ || prevents Internet filtering | ||
|} | |} |
Version du 18 septembre 2008 à 20:44
Amending | Amendended | Topic | Am. # | Source | Advice | Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Trautmann Art. 1.8.e | Framework Art. 8.4.g | Net Neutrality | 61 | ITRE | -- | notion of "lawful" threatens net neutrality and is out-of-scope of Telecoms Package |
Trautmann Art. 1.8.e | Framework Art. 8.4.g | Net Neutrality | 130=142 | IND/DEM, GUE/NGL | ++ | delete "lawful" |
Trautmann Art. 1.8.e | Framework Art. 8.4.ga | Net Neutrality | 131=143 | IND/DEM, GUE/NGL | ++ | restrictions can only be dicated by force majeure, network integrity and security or criminal law imposed for reasons of public policy, public security or public morality |
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea | Framework Art. 8.4.ga | Net Neutrality | 132 | Toubon, Hieronymi and al. | -- | opens door to 3-strikes approach |
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea | Framework Art. 8.4.ga | Net Neutrality | 137 | PPE-DE | -- | opens door to 3-strikes approach |
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea | Framework Art. 8.4.ga | Net Neutrality | 138 | Bono, Cohn-Bendit, Roithová and al. | +++ | restore judicial authority |
Trautmann Art. 1.8.ea | Framework Art. 8.4.g | Net Neutrality | 138 | Verts/ALE | ++ | retrictions subject to criminal law imposed for reasons of public policy, public security or public morality |
Trautmann Art. 1.9 | Framework Art. 9 | Net Neutrality | 64 | ITRE | -- | "cultural and media policy objectives" opens door to filtering, stick to "promotion of cultural and linguistic diversity" |
Trautmann Art. 2.6a | Authorisation Art. 9.1 | Net Neutrality | 98 | ITRE | -- | restrictions on access to services and applications" endangers net neutrality |
Trautmann Art. 2.8 | Authorisation Art. 12 | Net Neutrality | 100 | ITRE | -- | obligations about "intellectual property rights" (paragraph 2, point e) is out-of-scope |
Trautmann Art. 2.8.ba | Authorisation Art. 12.2 | Net Neutrality | 141 | Verts/ALE | ++ | delete obligations about "intellectual property rights" |
Trautmann Annex I.2.g | Access Annex I.A.19 | Net Neutrality | 120 | ITRE | ++ | deletion is good, since relation with EUCD and IPRED is out-of-scope |
Trautmann Chap. VI Art 55a | General Provisions | Internet Filtering | 133 | GUE/NGL | ++ | prevents Internet filtering |