Software patents directive 1st reading details by score : Différence entre versions
De La Quadrature du Net
Aller à la navigationAller à la rechercheLigne 586 : | Ligne 586 : | ||
|-id='MichaelGahler' style='display:none' | |-id='MichaelGahler' style='display:none' | ||
| [[MichaelGahler|Michael GAHLER]] || style="background:#ffff00" | 51.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | [[MichaelGahler|Michael GAHLER]] || style="background:#ffff00" | 51.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
− | |-id=' | + | |-id='GrahamBooth' style='display:none' |
− | | | + | | [[GrahamBooth|Graham BOOTH]] || style="background:#ffff00" | 51.1 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ffffff" | against || style="background:#ffffff" | against |
|-id='Villiers' style='display:none' | |-id='Villiers' style='display:none' | ||
| Villiers || style="background:#ffff00" | 51.1 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | Villiers || style="background:#ffff00" | 51.1 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
Ligne 616 : | Ligne 616 : | ||
|-id='DorisPack' style='display:none' | |-id='DorisPack' style='display:none' | ||
| [[DorisPack|Doris PACK]] || style="background:#ffff00" | 49.2 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | [[DorisPack|Doris PACK]] || style="background:#ffff00" | 49.2 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
− | |-id=' | + | |-id='MariaBerger' style='display:none' |
− | | | + | | [[MariaBerger|Maria BERGER]] || style="background:#ffff00" | 48.5 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for |
|-id='Duin' style='display:none' | |-id='Duin' style='display:none' | ||
| Duin || style="background:#ffff00" | 48.5 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | Duin || style="background:#ffff00" | 48.5 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
Ligne 998 : | Ligne 998 : | ||
|-id='Zimmerling' style='display:none' | |-id='Zimmerling' style='display:none' | ||
| Zimmerling || style="background:#ff6600" | 19.3 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | Zimmerling || style="background:#ff6600" | 19.3 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
− | |||
− | |||
|-id='Andria' style='display:none' | |-id='Andria' style='display:none' | ||
| Andria || style="background:#ff6600" | 18.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | Andria || style="background:#ff6600" | 18.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
Ligne 1 086 : | Ligne 1 084 : | ||
|-id='Pérez_Álvarez' style='display:none' | |-id='Pérez_Álvarez' style='display:none' | ||
| Pérez Álvarez || style="background:#ff6600" | 18.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | Pérez Álvarez || style="background:#ff6600" | 18.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
+ | |-id='AlexanderRadwan' style='display:none' | ||
+ | | [[AlexanderRadwan|Alexander RADWAN]] || style="background:#ff6600" | 18.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | ||
|-id='JoseIgnacioSalafrancaSanchezNeyra' style='display:none' | |-id='JoseIgnacioSalafrancaSanchezNeyra' style='display:none' | ||
| [[JoseIgnacioSalafrancaSanchezNeyra|José Ignacio SALAFRANCA SÁNCHEZ-NEYRA]] || style="background:#ff6600" | 18.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for | | [[JoseIgnacioSalafrancaSanchezNeyra|José Ignacio SALAFRANCA SÁNCHEZ-NEYRA]] || style="background:#ff6600" | 18.9 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for || style="background:#ffffff" | for |
Version du 7 février 2009 à 01:52
Political Memory: Directive on patentability of "computer-implemented inventions" (software patents), Results in Detail by Final Score
MEP | Final score | Amendments 52, 54/rév, 68 | Amendments 29, 41, 59 | Amendment 69 | Amendments 55/rév., 97, 108, 1st part | Amendment 16, 1st part | Amendment 16, 2nd part | Amendment 16 (paragraph 2) | Amendment 70 | Amendment 60 | Amendment 72 | Amendment 76, 1st part | Amendment 76, 2nd part | Amendment 71, 1st part | Amendment 71, 2nd part | Amendment 81 | Amendments 34, 115 | Amendment 74 | Amendment 75 | Proposition modifiée | Résolution |
---|
- Amendments 52, 54/rév, 68: Reject the directive - recommendation: for, coefficient: 4
- Amendments 29, 41, 59: Stated Purpose of directive: limits of patentability with respect to automated data processing - recommendation: for, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 69: Definition of technical contribution excluding processing, handling, and presentation of information - recommendation: for, coefficient: 5
- Amendments 55/rév., 97, 108, 1st part: Definition of a technical field by the use of controllable forces of nature - recommendation: for, coefficient: 5
- Amendment 16, 1st part: Definition of a computer-implemented invention - recommendation: against, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 16, 2nd part: Definition of inventive step by a technical contribution - recommendation: against, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 16 (paragraph 2): Requirement of a technical contribution to meet the inventive step requirement - recommendation: against, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 70: Definition of a technical contribution by constitution of a a new teaching on cause-effect relations in the use of controllable forces of nature - recommendation: for, coefficient: 5
- Amendment 60: Exclusion of computer-implemented solutions from patentability when they improve efficiency in the use of resources within the data processing system - recommendation: for, coefficient: 5
- Amendment 72: Inadmissibility of patent claims on a computer program, alone or on a data medium - recommendation: for, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 76, 1st part: No infringement when a patented technique is used for the purpose of interoperability - recommendation: for, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 76, 2nd part: Limitation of the absence of infringement by the three-steps test when a patented technique is use for the purpose of interoperability - recommendation: against, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 71, 1st part: Monitoring of directive with regard to SMEs' innovation - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- Amendment 71, 2nd part: Research of solutions to ease access to patents for SMEs - recommendation: against, coefficient: 2
- Amendment 81: Parlementary control of EPO - recommendation: for, coefficient: 3
- Amendments 34, 115: Delete a recital allowing patentability of algorithms - recommendation: for, coefficient: 4
- Amendment 74: Recital requiring that source code be include in a patent description - recommendation: against, coefficient: 2
- Amendment 75: Recital recalling patentability principles that exclude inventions belonging to public domain, implying that some software can be considered in this way and therefore could be patentable - recommendation: against, coefficient: 2
- Proposition modifiée: Proposition as amended - recommendation: none
- Résolution: Position of the European Parliament in first reading as stated in the previously amended proposition - recommendation: none