Difference between revisions of "Scusiblog global map of blocked servers"

From La Quadrature du Net
Jump to navigationJump to search
(traduction de -> en)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
translated from [http://scusiblog.org/?p=330 http://scusiblog.org/?p=330]
 
translated from [http://scusiblog.org/?p=330 http://scusiblog.org/?p=330]
  
 +
As you know, Germany is laboriously trying to implement a Web-censorship infrastructure.
  
In Deutschland wird ja fleißig versucht eine Web-Zensur-Infrastruktur aufzubauen.
+
I wonder why you try to conceal such illegal pages since you have access to the servers and, under these circumstances, you even have a chance to capture the heads.
  
In Germany, yes diligently tried a Web-censorship infrastructure.
+
Naive citizens probably think it will not work that way because the servers are likely located in countries which do not cooperate.
 
 
Ich frage mich, warum man versucht solche illegalen Seiten auszublenden, wenn man doch an die Server ran kommen kann, und so - unter Umständen - sogar eine Chance hat die Hintermänner zu erwischen?
 
 
 
I wonder why you try to hide these illegal sites, but if you ran on the server can, and - possibly - even has a chance behind the men to catch?
 
 
 
 
 
Naja, wahrscheinlich geht das nicht - denkt man als naiver Bürger - wahrscheinlich sind die Server in Ländern die nicht kooperieren.
 
 
 
Well, probably does not work that way - thinking as naive citizens - are likely to be the servers in countries which do not cooperate.
 
 
 
Ich hab mir die Listen der zu filternden Domains die bekannt sind genommen, und die Serverstandorte auf eine Karte übertragen, et voila:
 
 
 
I got me the filtered list of domains known to be followed, and the server locations on a card, et voila:
 
  
 +
I took a look at the known lists of filtered domains to draw a map of the server locations, et voila:
  
 
[[Image:dkfichse-world-chart.png|world chart]]
 
[[Image:dkfichse-world-chart.png|world chart]]
  
Legende: weiß = keine Server, grün = wenige Server, rot = viele Server
+
Legend: white = no server, green = few servers, red = lots of servers
 
 
Legend: white = no server, green = few servers, red = number of servers
 
 
 
Zahlen: Länder gesamt: 37
 
  
 
Figures: Countries Total: 37
 
Figures: Countries Total: 37
  
Rote Länder nach Zahlen: US: 3947, AU: 423, NL: 333, DE: 321, KR: 95, CA: 88,
+
Red countries by numbers: US: 3947, AU: 423, NL: 333, DE: 321, LR: 95, CA: 88,
 
 
Red countries by numbers: U.S.: 3947, AU: 423, NL: 333, EN: 321, LR: 95, CA: 88,
 
 
 
Braune Länder nach Zahlen: CZ: 62, RU: 61,GB: 59,
 
  
Brown by numbers Countries: Czech Republic: 62, RU: 61, GB: 59,
+
Brown countries by numbers: CZ: 62, RU: 61, GB: 59,
 
 
Dunkel-Grüne Länder nach Zahlen: SE: 31,BZ: 17, CN: 15, BS: 10,
 
  
 
Dark-green countries by numbers: SE: 31, BZ 17, CN: 15, BS: 10,
 
Dark-green countries by numbers: SE: 31, BZ 17, CN: 15, BS: 10,
  
Hell-Grüne Länder nach Zahlen: PT: 8, ES: 7, FR: 6, HK: 5, DK: 4, MX: 4, JP: 4, TH: 3, IL: 3, RO: 3, PA: 3, CY: 2, IT: 1, NO: 1, SC: 1, A2: 1, AT: 1, TW: 1, AN: 1, FI: 1, GI: 1, UA: 1, SK: 1, AF: 1
+
Light-green countries by numbers: PT: 8, ES: 7, FR: 6, HK: 5, DK: 4, MX: 4, JP: 4, TH: 3, IL: 3, RO: 3, PA: 3 , CY: 2 IT: 1, NO: 1, SC: 1, A2: 1, AT: 1, TW: 1, TO: 1, FI: 1, GI: 1, UA: 1, SK: 1, AF : 1
 
 
Bright-green Countries by Number: PT: 8, ES: 7, FR: 6, HK: 5, DK: 4, MX: 4, JP: 4, TH: 3, IL: 3, RO: 3, PA: 3 , CY: 2 IT: 1, NO: 1, SC: 1, A2: 1, AT: 1, TW: 1, TO: 1, FI: 1, GI: 1, UA: 1, SK: 1, AF : 1
 
 
 
Also die meisten der Webseiten wird auf Servern in Ländern gehostet in denen eine strafrechtliche Verfolgung durchaus möglich ist.
 
 
 
So most of the websites will be hosted on servers in countries where criminal prosecution is possible.
 
 
 
Die Deutsche Regierung muss sich dann halt auch mal Fragen lassen warum sie nichts gegen die 321 in Deutschland vorgehaltenen Angebote unternimmt.
 
  
The German government then has to stop sometimes questions why they have nothing against the 321 deals in Germany carried it.
 
  
Achso, doch - wir werde sie ja bald ausblenden, ich vergaß.
+
According to these figures, most websites are hosted on servers located in countries where criminal pursuit is perfectly possible.
  
Achso but - we will hide them so soon, I forgot.
+
The German government also has to answer some question concerning why they don't take action against the 321 offers located in Germany.
  
 +
Oh yes, I forgot, we will hide them soon.
  
Wen es interessiert hier sind noch die Bilder für die einzelnen Regionen der Welt (USA, Südamerika, Afrika, Naher Osten, Asien, Europa).
 
  
Who is interested here are the pictures for the various regions of the world (USA, South America, Africa, Middle East, Asia, Europe).
+
For those who might be interested, here are some pictures for various regions in the world.
  
USA: USA:
+
USA:
  
 
[[Image:dkfichse-usa-chart.png|USA chart]]
 
[[Image:dkfichse-usa-chart.png|USA chart]]
  
Südamerika: South America:
+
South America:
  
 
[[Image:dk_cencored_south_america-chart.png|South America chart]]
 
[[Image:dk_cencored_south_america-chart.png|South America chart]]
  
Afrika: Africa:
+
Africa:
  
 
[[Image:dkfichse-africa-chart.png|Africa chart]]
 
[[Image:dkfichse-africa-chart.png|Africa chart]]
  
Naher Osten: Middle East:
+
Middle East:
  
 
[[Image:dkfichse-middle_east-chart.png|Middle East chart]]
 
[[Image:dkfichse-middle_east-chart.png|Middle East chart]]
  
Asien: Asia:
+
Asia:
  
 
[[Image:dkfichse-asia-chart.png|Asia chart]]
 
[[Image:dkfichse-asia-chart.png|Asia chart]]
  
Europa: Europe:
+
Europe:
  
 
[[Image:dkfichse-europe-chart.png|Europe chart]]
 
[[Image:dkfichse-europe-chart.png|Europe chart]]
  
  
Update: Zu den Quellen der Listen und zu den technischen Aspekten kann man hier nachlesen.
+
Update: Sources and technical aspects can be read here.
 
 
Update: Among the sources of the lists and on the technical aspects can be read here.
 
 
 
  
Update 2: Einige Leute sagen, das ist alles nicht aussagekräftig, da sind viele domains dabei die es nicht mehr gibt oder die 'geparkt' sind.
+
Update 2: Some people say that not all of the data is meaningful since many of the domains do no longer exist or are "parked" domains.
  
Update 2: Some people say that everything is not meaningful, since many of the domains that no longer exists or the 'parked' are.
+
OK folks, I updated the list and cleaned it of any entries that don't exist anymore or designate parked domains.
  
OK, folks ich hab die Liste um alle Einträge bereinigt die nicht mehr existieren, die nicht auflösbar sind oder die geparkt sind.
+
Then there are 1413 entries left.
  
OK, folks I have the list of all entries adjusted to no longer exist, which are not resolvable or that are parked. Dann bleiben 1413 Einträge übrig. Then stay left over 1413 entries. Wenn man die nochmal durchjagt ergibt sich das folgende Bild: If the durchjagt again give the following picture:
+
I you do the analyzation again with the new results you obtain the following picture:
  
 
[[Image:dkfichse-world_cleaned-chart.png|cleaned world chart]]
 
[[Image:dkfichse-world_cleaned-chart.png|cleaned world chart]]
 
Die Zahlen dazu:
 
  
 
The figures about this:
 
The figures about this:
Line 110: Line 75:
 
US: 1038, AU: 135, CA: 85, NL: 41, DE: 26, CZ: 19, GB: 11, BS: 9, CN: 8, BZ: 8, RU: 5, KR: 4, DK: 2, MX: 4, FR: 4, ES: 1, IL: 1, AF: 1, SE: 1, NO: 1, PA: 1, A2: 1 U.S.: 1038, AU: 135, CA: 85, NL: 41 DE: 26, CZ: 19, GB: 11, BS: 9, CN: 8, BZ: 8, RU: 5, LR: 4, DK: 2, MX: 4, FR: 4, ES: 1, IL: 1, AF: 1, SE: 1, NO: 1, PA: 1, A2: 1
 
US: 1038, AU: 135, CA: 85, NL: 41, DE: 26, CZ: 19, GB: 11, BS: 9, CN: 8, BZ: 8, RU: 5, KR: 4, DK: 2, MX: 4, FR: 4, ES: 1, IL: 1, AF: 1, SE: 1, NO: 1, PA: 1, A2: 1 U.S.: 1038, AU: 135, CA: 85, NL: 41 DE: 26, CZ: 19, GB: 11, BS: 9, CN: 8, BZ: 8, RU: 5, LR: 4, DK: 2, MX: 4, FR: 4, ES: 1, IL: 1, AF: 1, SE: 1, NO: 1, PA: 1, A2: 1
  
Was bleibt ist die Tatsache, daß die Listen mitunter relativ alt sind, so ca. ein Jahr scheint es.
+
This shows us that the lists are often very old, about one year average.
 
 
What remains is the fact that the lists are sometimes relatively old, so about a year, it seems.
 
 
 
Daran kann ich leider erstmal nichts ändern.
 
  
That I can not change first.
+
This is something I cannot currently change.
  
Aber ich freue mich über anonyme emails , wenn die jemand mal leaken möchte.
 
  
But I am on anonymous emails, if someone wants to leak times.
+
However I'm looking forward to anonymous e-mails, if somebody wants to leak something.
  
  
 
Update 3:
 
Update 3:
Die aus Update2 übrig gebliebenen 26 Server in .de hab ich mir mal angesehen, viele sind einfach auf Werbeseiten weitergeleitet, manche Zeigen Fehlermeldungen oder gar nichts, aber es gibt auch noch aktive Seiten mit sehr fragwürdigem Inhalt darunter, zum Beispiel diese: **********.info [**.***.**.**] **-***-**-**.internetserviceteam.com
+
I took a closer look at the 26 servers stationed in .de that were left from Update 2. A lot simply redirect to advertising pages, some show an error message or nothing at all. However some are still active and exhibit very questionable content, for example: **********.info [**.***.**.**] **-***-**-**.internetserviceteam.com
 
 
The leftover from Update2 server in 26. I've de views, many are simply on advertising pages, show some error messages or nothing at all, but there are very active sites with questionable content including, for example these: **********.info [**.***.**.**] **-***-**-**.internetserviceteam.com
 
 
 
Achtung: Es könnte illegal sein auf diese Seite zu gehen, keine Ahnung bin kein Anwalt.
 
 
 
Caution: It might be illegal on this page to go, I do not know am not a lawyer.
 
 
 
Also auf der Seite sind lauter Fotos von Kindern und jungen Mädchen in teils mehr, teils weniger aufreizenden Posen.
 
 
 
So on the page are all photographs of children and young girls in some more, some less provocative poses.
 
 
 
Kann sein das dass noch haarscharf vom Gesetz gedeckt ist, ich kenne mich in der juristischen Bewertung solcher Sachen nicht aus, Keine Ahnung.
 
 
 
It may be that the hair sharply yet covered by the law is, I am in the legal assessment of such property are not made, I do not know.
 
 
 
Aber wenn der Inhalt dieser Seite illegal sein sollte, dann fragt sich schon warum dieser Eintrag aus einer Zensurliste die so ca. ein Jahr alt ist am heutigen Tag immer noch aktiv ist.
 
 
 
But if the content of this page should be illegal, then ask yourself why has this entry from a list censorship as about a year old today is still active.
 
  
Falls die Seite nicht illegal sein sollte frage ich mich warum man die sperrt und ob es dafür dann eine gesetzliche Grundlage gibt.
 
  
If the page should not be illegal, I wonder why the locks and then whether there is a statutory basis.
+
*Caution: It might be illegal to navigate to these pages, I don't not know, I am not a lawyer.*
  
Falls mich zu den juristischen Fragen - in diesen Themen bewanderter - Leser aufklären möchte, gerne!
+
The page shows a lot of photographs of children and young girls in more or less provocative poses.
  
If I am on the legal issues - these issues watching - enlighten readers want to be happy!
+
Maybe this is kind of content is not yet totally covered by law, I do not have any experience in such legal assessments.
  
 +
However, if this content is illegal then I wonder why this entry from a ± 1 year old censorship listing is still active at this day.
  
Update 4: Update 4:
+
If the page is not illegal then I wonder why it is being blocked and whether there is a legal basis for this.
Ich hab eine neue - aktuellere - Liste für Finnland gefunden.
 
  
I have a new - updated - list for Finland found.
+
I some knowledgeable readers want to enlighten me on these legal issues I would be more than happy!
  
Stammt wohl aus dem Dezember 2008 - also gerade mal 8 Wochen alt.
 
  
Probably stems from the December 2008 - that is just 8 weeks old.
+
Update 4:
 +
I found a new, updated, list for Finland.
  
Alles weiter unter Neue Liste - Neue Bilder.
+
Seems to stem from December 2008, about eight weeks old.
  
Everything below New List - New pictures.
 
  
 +
Everything under: New List - New pictures.
  
Update 5 Update 5
 
Einer meiner Leser hat dem Hoster von **********.info eine Email geschrieben und 10 Minuten später war die Seite offline.
 
  
One of my readers sent the host of the **********.info write an email and 10 minutes later the site was offline.
+
Update 5
  
Geht doch, warum kann so was das BKA nicht, wo sie doch praktisch ein Jahr Zeit gehabt hätten die Zensurliste ihrer finnischen Kollegen mal durchzugehen und die Server in DE 'ermitteln'. Siehe Kommentar
+
One of my readers sent an e-mail to the hoster of **********.info and ten minutes later the site went offline.
  
If they do, so why can not what the BKA, where they almost a year had the censorship list of their Finnish counterparts times and go through the servers in U.S. 'determined'. See comment
+
You can see that it works, why can't the BKA (Federal Criminal Police Office) do this, even though they had about one year dig through the Finnish censorship listing.
 +
erver in DE 'ermitteln'. Siehe Kommentar

Revision as of 14:45, 14 July 2009

translated from http://scusiblog.org/?p=330

As you know, Germany is laboriously trying to implement a Web-censorship infrastructure.

I wonder why you try to conceal such illegal pages since you have access to the servers and, under these circumstances, you even have a chance to capture the heads.

Naive citizens probably think it will not work that way because the servers are likely located in countries which do not cooperate.

I took a look at the known lists of filtered domains to draw a map of the server locations, et voila:

world chart

Legend: white = no server, green = few servers, red = lots of servers

Figures: Countries Total: 37

Red countries by numbers: US: 3947, AU: 423, NL: 333, DE: 321, LR: 95, CA: 88,

Brown countries by numbers: CZ: 62, RU: 61, GB: 59,

Dark-green countries by numbers: SE: 31, BZ 17, CN: 15, BS: 10,

Light-green countries by numbers: PT: 8, ES: 7, FR: 6, HK: 5, DK: 4, MX: 4, JP: 4, TH: 3, IL: 3, RO: 3, PA: 3 , CY: 2 IT: 1, NO: 1, SC: 1, A2: 1, AT: 1, TW: 1, TO: 1, FI: 1, GI: 1, UA: 1, SK: 1, AF : 1


According to these figures, most websites are hosted on servers located in countries where criminal pursuit is perfectly possible.

The German government also has to answer some question concerning why they don't take action against the 321 offers located in Germany.

Oh yes, I forgot, we will hide them soon.


For those who might be interested, here are some pictures for various regions in the world.

USA:

USA chart

South America:

South America chart

Africa:

Africa chart

Middle East:

Middle East chart

Asia:

Asia chart

Europe:

Europe chart


Update: Sources and technical aspects can be read here.

Update 2: Some people say that not all of the data is meaningful since many of the domains do no longer exist or are "parked" domains.

OK folks, I updated the list and cleaned it of any entries that don't exist anymore or designate parked domains.

Then there are 1413 entries left.

I you do the analyzation again with the new results you obtain the following picture:

cleaned world chart

The figures about this:

US: 1038, AU: 135, CA: 85, NL: 41, DE: 26, CZ: 19, GB: 11, BS: 9, CN: 8, BZ: 8, RU: 5, KR: 4, DK: 2, MX: 4, FR: 4, ES: 1, IL: 1, AF: 1, SE: 1, NO: 1, PA: 1, A2: 1 U.S.: 1038, AU: 135, CA: 85, NL: 41 DE: 26, CZ: 19, GB: 11, BS: 9, CN: 8, BZ: 8, RU: 5, LR: 4, DK: 2, MX: 4, FR: 4, ES: 1, IL: 1, AF: 1, SE: 1, NO: 1, PA: 1, A2: 1

This shows us that the lists are often very old, about one year average.

This is something I cannot currently change.


However I'm looking forward to anonymous e-mails, if somebody wants to leak something.


Update 3: I took a closer look at the 26 servers stationed in .de that were left from Update 2. A lot simply redirect to advertising pages, some show an error message or nothing at all. However some are still active and exhibit very questionable content, for example: **********.info [**.***.**.**] **-***-**-**.internetserviceteam.com


  • Caution: It might be illegal to navigate to these pages, I don't not know, I am not a lawyer.*

The page shows a lot of photographs of children and young girls in more or less provocative poses.

Maybe this is kind of content is not yet totally covered by law, I do not have any experience in such legal assessments.

However, if this content is illegal then I wonder why this entry from a ± 1 year old censorship listing is still active at this day.

If the page is not illegal then I wonder why it is being blocked and whether there is a legal basis for this.

I some knowledgeable readers want to enlighten me on these legal issues I would be more than happy!


Update 4: I found a new, updated, list for Finland.

Seems to stem from December 2008, about eight weeks old.


Everything under: New List - New pictures.


Update 5

One of my readers sent an e-mail to the hoster of **********.info and ten minutes later the site went offline.

You can see that it works, why can't the BKA (Federal Criminal Police Office) do this, even though they had about one year dig through the Finnish censorship listing. erver in DE 'ermitteln'. Siehe Kommentar