Version du 2 juin 2009 à 19:47
Political Memory: Criminal measures aimed at ensuring the enforcement of intellectual property rights (IPRED 2), Results in Detail for Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs
for Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs==
MEP |
Final score |
ams. 43+44 |
am. 46/1 |
am. 46/2 |
am. 46/3 |
am. 46/4 |
am. 46/5 |
ams. 39+59/1 |
ams. 39+59/2 |
ams. 39+59/3 |
ams. 39+59/4 |
ams. 39+59/5 |
am. 38 |
ams. 50+64 |
am. 16 |
ams. 54+60 |
am. 61 |
ams. 57+62 |
amended Commission proposal |
resolution
|
Jean LAMBERT |
89.5 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Giusto CATANIA |
84.2 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Athanasios PAFILIS |
84.2 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Eva-Britt SVENSSON |
84.2 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Søren Bo SØNDERGAARD |
84.2 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Inger SEGELSTRÖM |
82.9 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
abst. |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against
|
Elly de GROEN-KOUWENHOVEN |
81.6 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
- |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
- |
for |
against |
against
|
Tatjana ŽDANOKA |
81.6 |
for |
for |
- |
for |
- |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Kathalijne Maria BUITENWEG |
80.3 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
- |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Marine LE PEN |
80.3 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
abst. |
against |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against
|
Kartika Tamara LIOTARD |
80.3 |
for |
- |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Philip BRADBOURN |
78.9 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Cem ÖZDEMIR |
77.6 |
for |
for |
- |
for |
for |
for |
against |
- |
for |
against |
against |
against |
- |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Luca ROMAGNOLI |
75.0 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
abst. |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against
|
Charles TANNOCK |
73.7 |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Sylvia-Yvonne KAUFMANN |
72.4 |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
abst. |
for |
for |
for |
for |
abst. |
abst.
|
Roger KNAPMAN |
71.1 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
- |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
abst. |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Johannes VOGGENHUBER |
69.7 |
for |
for |
- |
for |
for |
- |
- |
against |
for |
- |
- |
- |
- |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against
|
Mario BORGHEZIO |
68.4 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
abst. |
for |
abst. |
for |
for |
against |
for |
abst. |
abst.
|
Henrik LAX |
68.4 |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Adina-Ioana VĂLEAN |
68.4 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Jan ZAHRADIL |
68.4 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Koenraad DILLEN |
67.1 |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
- |
for |
- |
for |
for |
abst. |
against |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against
|
Marco CAPPATO |
64.5 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against
|
Alexander ALVARO |
63.2 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Sophia in 't VELD |
63.2 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Bill NEWTON DUNN |
63.2 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Siiri OVIIR |
61.8 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
- |
for
|
Maria CARLSHAMRE |
61.8 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against
|
Marco PANNELLA |
60.5 |
against |
against |
for |
for |
- |
for |
against |
- |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Ignasi GUARDANS CAMBÓ |
59.2 |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
- |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Baroness Sarah LUDFORD |
56.6 |
against |
for |
for |
- |
for |
- |
against |
- |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Stavros LAMBRINIDIS |
53.9 |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
- |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
for |
for
|
Charlotte CEDERSCHIÖLD |
47.4 |
for |
- |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
- |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
- |
against |
against
|
Konrad SZYMAŃSKI |
43.4 |
- |
against |
- |
for |
- |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Adamos ADAMOU |
42.1 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
against
|
Evelyne GEBHARDT |
40.8 |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
abst. |
abst.
|
Bogusław ROGALSKI |
38.2 |
for |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
abst. |
against |
against |
against
|
Michael CASHMAN |
36.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Viktória MOHÁCSI |
35.5 |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
for |
- |
for |
against |
for |
against |
- |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Gérard DEPREZ |
31.6 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Hanna FOLTYN-KUBICKA |
31.6 |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Ville ITÄLÄ |
31.6 |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for
|
Bogdan PĘK |
31.6 |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Daciana Octavia SÂRBU |
31.6 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for
|
Jeanine HENNIS-PLASSCHAERT |
28.9 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
abst. |
- |
abst. |
against |
abst. |
for |
- |
abst. |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against
|
Agustín DÍAZ DE MERA GARCÍA CONSUEGRA |
26.3 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Carlos José ITURGAIZ ANGULO |
26.3 |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
- |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Jaime MAYOR OREJA |
26.3 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Christine DE VEYRAC |
26.3 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Wolfgang KREISSL-DÖRFLER |
25.0 |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
- |
abst. |
abst. |
abst. |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Magda KÓSÁNÉ KOVÁCS |
23.7 |
against |
- |
- |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Ioannis VARVITSIOTIS |
23.7 |
abst. |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
- |
for |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for
|
Emine BOZKURT |
22.4 |
against |
for |
- |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Simon BUSUTTIL |
22.4 |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Genowefa GRABOWSKA |
22.4 |
- |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Katalin LÉVAI |
22.4 |
against |
for |
- |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Rainer WIELAND |
22.4 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
- |
against |
against |
for |
against
|
Monika BEŇOVÁ |
21.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Maria da Assunção ESTEVES |
21.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Patrick GAUBERT |
21.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Roland GEWALT |
21.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Hubert PIRKER |
21.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Esther de LANGE |
21.1 |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Panayiotis DEMETRIOU |
19.7 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
- |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Lívia JÁRÓKA |
18.4 |
against |
against |
- |
- |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Giorgos DIMITRAKOPOULOS |
17.1 |
- |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Bárbara DÜHRKOP DÜHRKOP |
17.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZ |
17.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
- |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Kinga GÁL |
17.1 |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Ona JUKNEVIČIENĖ |
17.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
- |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
against
|
Claude MORAES |
17.1 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
- |
for |
against |
for |
for |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for
|
Alfredo ANTONIOZZI |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Edit BAUER |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Mihael BREJC |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Frieda BREPOELS |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Carlo CASINI |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Carlos COELHO |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Claudio FAVA |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Anne FERREIRA |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Ewa KLAMT |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Jörg LEICHTFRIED |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Marian-Jean MARINESCU |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZ |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Martine ROURE |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
María Isabel SALINAS GARCÍA |
15.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Luis HERRERO-TEJEDOR |
13.2 |
against |
against |
against |
- |
against |
against |
for |
- |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
for |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Manfred WEBER |
11.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Stefano ZAPPALA' |
11.8 |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
for |
against |
- |
against |
against |
against |
for |
for
|
Show details for all MEPs
- ams. 43+44: Reject the directive - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/1: Limit to copyright and trademarks - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/2: Limit directive to commercial counterfeiting - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/3: Limit directive to commercial counterfeiting - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/4: Require malicious intent - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/5: Apply to legal persons - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/1: Includes unexamined, unclear IPRs (design and database rights) - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/2: Limit scope to copyright and trademarks - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/3: “Commercial scale” definition does not exclude private users (second part is explanatory, not laying down a limit). “Paying less” = “commercial advantage” - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/4: “intentional” definition is weak and unclear (replace “commercial scale” with its definition -> “obtain an economic advantage on a commercial advantage”) - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/5: Apply to legal persons - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 38: Second part only excludes imports authorised by the rights holder, which is not an infringement in the first place. Unauthorised parallel imports should be excluded, since these are not counterfeited products. - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 50+64: Excludes inciting/aiding/abetting - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 16: Protect journalists, teachers, commentators, researchers - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 54+60: Ensure C-176/03 conformance - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 61: Punish abuse of this directive - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 57+62: Protect neutrality of investigation - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- amended Commission proposal: Proposition as amended - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- resolution: Position of the European Parliament in first reading as stated in the previously amended proposition - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
Back to results for Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs]