Analysis of answers to IPRED consultation
Last Winter, the European Commission organized a large consultation on the future of IPRED, which is the main EU instrument in the war against the online sharing of culture. If the EU Parliament fails to reject the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA) in its upcoming consent vote, the revision of IPRED will be the perfect vehicle to transpose in EU law the dangerous censorship schemes pushed by ACTA's digital chapter (visit http://lqdn.fr/en/acta to join the campaign against ACTA).
All sorts of stakeholders - be they Member States, businesses federations, corporations, lobbies, non-governmental organizations - have sent answers to the consultation (you can read La Quadrature's answer here). These submissions are listed below.
How to Help: Everybody interested in helping out can start reading a submission and identify each stakeholder's position regarding the war on sharing of cultural works online. Copy-paste key excerpts of the submissions in relevant sections. Please provide a short sentence in english if the quoted text is unclear or in another language.
What to look for: What does a given stakeholder think of the EU Commission's plans to step up copyright enforcement by turning Web service providers (such as search engines hosting services) as well as telecom operators into a private copyright police? To quickly analyse the submissions, you should be looking for three key issues:
- Greater liability of Internet service providers. According to existing law, Internet service providers (ISPs) are not legally responsible for the activity carried on by their users (thanks to the 2000 e-Commerce directive). These liability exemptions ensure that ISPs do not monitor their users' activity or restrict their freedom of communication. The Commission's consultation shows that it wants to bypass these liability exemptions, and enroll these actors to police their networks and services at the expense of their users' fundamental rights. Does the stakeholder show support to the liability exemptions, or does it call on ISPs to take a more proactive role in the war on sharing?
- Cooperation between ISPs and copyright-holders. A growing number of policy-making efforts make references to "cooperation", "self-regulation" or "voluntary agreement", so as to turn Internet intermediaries into the gatekeepers of online communications in the war on sharing. Does the submission include such references"?
- Measures against copyright infringement, such as filtering. According to the Commission: "Internet platforms such as online market places or search engines can also play an important role in reducing the number of the infringements, in particular through *preventive measures* and ‘notice and take-down’ policies". Clearly, the Commission would also like to generalize wide-filtering schemes. Does the stakeholder criticize such dangerous scheme, or does it endorse them?
See templates Bascap, France and Business Europe.
Sommaire
- 1 Analysis of submissions to IPRED consultation
- 1.1 Public authorities
- 1.1.1 Ak Oesterreich (de)
- 1.1.2 Belgium (en)
- 1.1.3 Bulgaria (en)
- 1.1.4 Czech Republic (en)
- 1.1.5 Danish Chamber Of Commerce (en)
- 1.1.6 Denmark (en)
- 1.1.7 Deutscher Bundestag (de)
- 1.1.8 European Parliament Committee On Legal Affairs (en)
- 1.1.9 Finland Ministry Of Employment And Economy (en)
- 1.1.10 France
- 1.1.11 Germany (de)
- 1.1.12 Hadopi (fr)
- 1.1.13 Hungary Ministry Public administration And Justice (en)
- 1.1.14 Ireland (en)
- 1.1.15 Italy Ministry Of Agrifood (en)
- 1.1.16 Italy Office Of The Prime Minister (it)
- 1.1.17 Latvia (en)
- 1.1.18 Lithuania Ministry Culture (lt)
- 1.1.19 Malta (en)
- 1.1.20 Netherlands Ministry Security Justice (nl)
- 1.1.21 Poland Ministry Culture (en, pl)
- 1.1.22 Portugal (pt)
- 1.1.23 Romania (en, ro)
- 1.1.24 Slovakia (sk)
- 1.1.25 Spain Ministry Of Justice (es)
- 1.1.26 Uk Governement
- 1.1.27 Wko Austria (de)
- 1.2 Organisations
- 1.2.1 Act (en)
- 1.2.2 Aepoc (en)
- 1.2.3 Afep (fr)
- 1.2.4 Aim (en)
- 1.2.5 Aippi Belgium (en)
- 1.2.6 Aippi Finland (en)
- 1.2.7 Aippi General Secretariat (en)
- 1.2.8 Allegroup (en)
- 1.2.9 Alliance Against Ip Theft (en)
- 1.2.10 Alstom (en)
- 1.2.11 Andema (en)
- 1.2.12 Anica Fapav Univideo (en)
- 1.2.13 Apm (de)
- 1.2.14 Apram (fr)
- 1.2.15 April (fr)
- 1.2.16 Apt (it)
- 1.2.17 Association Francaise Ubuntu (fr)
- 1.2.18 Assotelecomunicazioni Asstel (en)
- 1.2.19 Aukro Bulgaria (en)
- 1.2.20 Aukro Czech Rep (en)
- 1.2.21 Aukro Slovakia (en)
- 1.2.22 Bascap (en)
- 1.2.23 Bdwi (de)
- 1.2.24 Bdzv Vdz En (de)
- 1.2.25 Benelux Verenging Voor Merken En Modellenrecht (nl)
- 1.2.26 Beuc (en)
- 1.2.27 Bits Of Freedom (en)
- 1.2.28 Boev (de)
- 1.2.29 Bouygues (fr)
- 1.2.30 Brein (en)
- 1.2.31 Bsa (en)
- 1.2.32 Bskyb (en)
- 1.2.33 Businesseurope (en)
- 1.2.34 Bwin Party (en)
- 1.2.35 Cable Europe (en)
- 1.2.36 Cable Europe Ecta Etno Euroispa Gsma (en)
- 1.2.37 Ccia (en)
- 1.2.38 Ccip (fr)
- 1.2.39 Ccip Fiche Synthese (fr)
- 1.2.40 Cefic (en)
- 1.2.41 Ceipi (fr)
- 1.2.42 Cepi Fera Fiad Fiapf Ivf (en)
- 1.2.43 Chartered Institute Of Pa (en)
- 1.2.44 Cmba (en)
- 1.2.45 Cnac (fr)
- 1.2.46 Colipa (en)
- 1.2.47 Comite Colbert (fr)
- 1.2.48 Confindustria (it)
- 1.2.49 Confindustria Servizi Innovativi E Tecnologici (it)
- 1.2.50 Constant (fr)
- 1.2.51 Consumer Focus (en)
- 1.2.52 Dacs (en)
- 1.2.53 Danish Copyright Council (en)
- 1.2.54 Danish Patent Agents Association (en)
- 1.2.55 Danske Universiteter (dk)
- 1.2.56 Dbf (fr)
- 1.2.57 Deutsche Patentanwaltskammer (de)
- 1.2.58 Deutsche Patentanwaltskammer Cover (de)
- 1.2.59 Deutsche Post Dhl (en)
- 1.2.60 Deutsche Telekom (en)
- 1.2.61 Deutscher Anwaltverein (de)
- 1.2.62 Deutscher Markenverband (de)
- 1.2.63 Dihk (de)
- 1.2.64 Eaea (en)
- 1.2.65 Ebay (en)
- 1.2.66 Ebca (en)
- 1.2.67 Ebf Contribution (en)
- 1.2.68 Eccia (en)
- 1.2.69 Ecta (en)
- 1.2.70 Edima (en)
- 1.2.71 Edps (en)
- 1.2.72 Edri (en)
- 1.2.73 Efpia (en)
- 1.2.74 Egdf (en)
- 1.2.75 Egeda (en)
- 1.2.76 Egma (en)
- 1.2.77 Eli Lilly (en)
- 1.2.78 Emeca (en)
- 1.2.79 Enpa50 (en)
- 1.2.80 Epa (en)
- 1.2.81 Ericsson (en)
- 1.2.82 Esa (en)
- 1.2.83 Etno (en)
- 1.2.84 Eurocopya (en)
- 1.2.85 Euroispa (en)
- 1.2.86 European Fashion Council (en)
- 1.2.87 European Producers Club (fr)
- 1.2.88 European Publishers Council (en)
- 1.2.89 Faep (en)
- 1.2.90 Fast
- 1.2.91 Fastweb (en)
- 1.2.92 Fdn (fr)
- 1.2.93 Fep (en)
- 1.2.94 Fesi (en)
- 1.2.95 Ffii (en)
- 1.2.96 Finnish Commerce Federation (fi)
- 1.2.97 Fimi (en)
- 1.2.98 Fondation Giacometti (fr)
- 1.2.99 Fondation Hartung-bergman (fr)
- 1.2.100 Fondation Le Corbusier (fr)
- 1.2.101 Fox International Channels (en)
- 1.2.102 Fsfe (en)
- 1.2.103 Gema (de)
- 1.2.104 Gesac (en)
- 1.2.105 Gi Dpi (es)
- 1.2.106 Giart (en)
- 1.2.107 Gleiss Lutz (en)
- 1.2.108 Google (en)
- 1.2.109 Grupa Allegro (en)
- 1.2.110 Grur (de, en)
- 1.2.111 Gsma europe (en)
- 1.2.112 Hai Europe (en)
- 1.2.113 Icc (en)
- 1.2.114 Icmp (en)
- 1.2.115 Ifpi (en)
- 1.2.116 Ifrro (en)
- 1.2.117 Indicam (en)
- 1.2.118 Inta (en)
- 1.2.119 Intel (en)
- 1.2.120 Internet Society (en)
- 1.2.121 Internet Society Poland Panoptykon (pl)
- 1.2.122 Ip Federation (en)
- 1.2.123 Ipo (en)
- 1.2.124 Isfe (en)
- 1.2.125 Ispa Austria (en)
- 1.2.126 Ispa Belgium (en)
- 1.2.127 Iuridicum Remedium (en)
- 1.2.128 Johan Schl�ter Advokatfirma (dk, en)
- 1.2.129 Kepka (en)
- 1.2.130 Kopiosto (fi)
- 1.2.131 Ksb Sas (fr)
- 1.2.132 La Quadrature Du Net (en)
- 1.2.133 La-ex Fcforum (en)
- 1.2.134 Les (en)
- 1.2.135 Lesi (en)
- 1.2.136 Lyhty (fi)
- 1.2.137 Marques (en)
- 1.2.138 Medef (fr)
- 1.2.139 Mediaset (en)
- 1.2.140 Microsoft (en)
- 1.2.141 Mih (en)
- 1.2.142 Mpa (en)
- 1.2.143 Nuovo Imaie (en)
- 1.2.144 Nurpa (en)
- 1.2.145 ORG (en)
- 1.2.146 Parti Pirate (fr)
- 1.2.147 Philips (en)
- 1.2.148 Pike (pl)
- 1.2.149 Pin Sme (en)
- 1.2.150 Pirelli (en)
- 1.2.151 Ppl Uk (en)
- 1.2.152 Publishers Association (en)
- 1.2.153 Qdlaty (en)
- 1.2.154 Qxl Ricardo Denmark (en)
- 1.2.155 Qxl Ricardo Greece (en)
- 1.2.156 Rga (en)
- 1.2.157 Rim (en)
- 1.2.158 Royal Tnt Post (en)
- 1.2.159 Royal Tnt Post Taxud (en)
- 1.2.160 Saa (en)
- 1.2.161 Sabam Form figures (en)
- 1.2.162 Sabam Questionnaire (en)
- 1.2.163 Sacd (fr)
- 1.2.164 Sacg (en)
- 1.2.165 Sazas (si)
- 1.2.166 Sek (fi)
- 1.2.167 Sroc (en)
- 1.2.168 Stm (en)
- 1.2.169 Stop43 (en)
- 1.2.170 Stowarzyszenie Portal Otwartej Informacji (pl)
- 1.2.171 Sty (en)
- 1.2.172 Suomen Yritt�j�t (fi)
- 1.2.173 Swedish Publishers Association (en)
- 1.2.174 Tacd (en)
- 1.2.175 Tee (fr)
- 1.2.176 Telecom Italia (en)
- 1.2.177 Telefonica (en)
- 1.2.178 Teva (en)
- 1.2.179 Tie (en)
- 1.2.180 Tsic (en)
- 1.2.181 Ttvk Finnish Organisation (fi)
- 1.2.182 Tuotos (fi)
- 1.2.183 Uk Music (en)
- 1.2.184 Unifab (fr)
- 1.2.185 Union (en)
- 1.2.186 Upu (en, fr)
- 1.2.187 Vdma (de)
- 1.2.188 Ver.di (de)
- 1.2.189 Vit Hnilica (cz)
- 1.2.190 Vno Ncw Mkb Nederland (en)
- 1.2.191 Voez (en)
- 1.2.192 Vprt (de)
- 1.2.193 Vrijschrift (en)
- 1.2.194 Vzbv (de)
- 1.1 Public authorities
Analysis of submissions to IPRED consultation
Public authorities
Ak Oesterreich (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Belgium (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Bulgaria (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Czech Republic (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Danish Chamber Of Commerce (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Denmark (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Deutscher Bundestag (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
European Parliament Committee On Legal Affairs (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Finland Ministry Of Employment And Economy (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
France
- Increased liability of ISPs
'Les Autorités françaises partagent également le souhait de la Commission d’étudier les possibilités d’impliquer « plus étroitement les intermédiaires, compte tenu de leur position favorable pour contribuer à prévenir les infractions en ligne et à y mettre fin. (...) Toute référence à la directive 2004/48/CE ne peut raisonnablement faire abstraction de la question des catégories d'intermédiaires telles qu'elles résultent de la directive 2000/31/CE sur le commerce électronique. A cet égard, la Commission a entamé également une réflexion sur l’évaluation de la directive 2000/31 relative au commerce électronique, incluant un examen de l’encadrement global des prestataires de services Internet.
Il convient dans ce cadre de réfléchir aux catégories de prestataires techniques et à la portée des régimes qui leur ont été reconnus compte tenu de l’évolution technologique et des usages depuis le moment où la directive a été adoptée. Une articulation étroite entre ces deux exercices (évaluations des directives 2004/48/CE et 2000/31/CE) doit donc être menée, sans pour autant limiter la notion d'intermédiaire au sens de la directive 2004/48/CE à la liste des prestataires intermédiaires définis à l'article 12 de la directive 2000/31/CE.
Summary: Assessment of IPRED should be made in conjunction with the ongoing assessmen of the liability exemptions of eCommerce
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
Il pourrait également être envisagé une forme d'obligation de coopération des intermédiaires techniques en vue de prévenir ou de faire cesser une atteinte à un droit de propriété intellectuelle. La coopération des acteurs est un impératif pour la protection des droits de propriété intellectuelle. De ce point de vue, un progrès important consiste en la mise en place de dispositifs d'empreintes qui constituent un moyen intéressant de contribuer à lutter contre le piratage.
Summary: A form of obligation to cooperate (sic) could be considered in order to prevent infringements and address further infringements of intellectual prperty right (...). In this respect, fingerprinting represents an interesting means of fighting against piracy.
- Repression against further copyright infringements
Un progrès important consiste en la mise en place de dispositifs d'empreintes qui constituent un moyen intéressant de contribuer à lutter contre le piratage. (...) La procédure dite de "notification et retrait" pourrait être précisée afin d'indiquer qu'elle prévoit d'éviter la nouvelle remise en ligne par un autre utilisateur du même contenu contrefaisant le droit d'auteur ou les droits voisins (procédure "notice and keep off" ou "notice, take down & stay down"). Cette mesure n'est qu'un exemple qui ne doit pas limiter une réflexion plus large sur les mesures préventives de filtrage et de détection des contrefaçons.
Summary: Notice and Takedown procedure should be completed to stress that intermediaries should avoid any reposting by another user of the same copyright infringing content. This measure is only one example that should not hamper a broader reflexion on preventive measures of filtering and detecting infringements.
Germany (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Hadopi (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Hungary Ministry Public administration And Justice (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ireland (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Italy Ministry Of Agrifood (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Italy Office Of The Prime Minister (it)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Latvia (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Lithuania Ministry Culture (lt)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Malta (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Netherlands Ministry Security Justice (nl)
- netherlands_ministry_security_justice_nl.pdf
- netherlands_ministry_security_justice_annex1_nl.pdf
- netherlands_ministry_security_justice_annex2_nl.pdf
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Poland Ministry Culture (en, pl)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Portugal (pt)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Romania (en, ro)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Slovakia (sk)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Spain Ministry Of Justice (es)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Uk Governement
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Wko Austria (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Organisations
Act (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aepoc (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Afep (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aim (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aippi Belgium (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aippi Finland (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aippi General Secretariat (en)
- aippi_general_secretariat_en.pdf
- aippi_general_secretariat_annex1_q163 _en.pdf
- aippi_general_secretariat_annex2_q216_resolution_en.pdf
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Allegroup (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Alliance Against Ip Theft (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Alstom (en)
Alstom does not consider directly the problem of copyright infringement. Its participation to the IPRED revision process concerns industrial issues, namely competition with foreign companies that infringe on its industrial property, patent rulings, and trade secrets. Most of its answer is indeed a statement from the "Trade Secrets & Innovation Coalition" (TSIC), a lobby that gathers Alstom, CEFIC, DuPont de Nemours, Michelin, Nestlé, Procter & Gamble and Solvay, inter alia.
The purpose of the TSIC lobby is to have trade secrets acknowledged as a form of IPR protected by the IPRED directive. In their opinion, "know-how"s should be protected as patents are. This is a dangerous trend. While patents have been filed and published, as a counterpart to the public for the granted monopoly, know-hows can be freely rediscovered by third parties that acquire knowledge by self experience. Being able to sue a third party that gains some knowledge on the basis that this knowledge is considered a trade secret is mere nonsense. A company uses either the patents and trades off publicity for secrecy, or else uses trade secrets without further protection. One cannot have both the butter and the money for the butter.
Alstom also wishes a black list of "IP-unfriendly" foreign companies, that could be used to ban their imports without judging whether the imported goods actually infringe or not. Chinese companies are specifically targeted.
Alstom wishes to have a unified patent court at the EU level.
- Increased liability of ISPs
N/A
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
N/A
- Repression against further copyright infringements
N/A
Andema (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Anica Fapav Univideo (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Apm (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Apram (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
April (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Apt (it)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Association Francaise Ubuntu (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here] NO
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here] NO
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here] NO
Assotelecomunicazioni Asstel (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aukro Bulgaria (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aukro Czech Rep (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Aukro Slovakia (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Bascap (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here] Some Member States have taken the view that injunctions against intermediaries are only allowed if the intermediary itself is found to be aiding and abetting or otherwise is held liable for its customer’s or user’s infringement. Several Member States similarly restrict the availability of interlocutory injunctions under Article 9 of the Directive. There is no mention of any such restrictions in the Directive, and these only encourage unnecessary litigation against intermediaries. It would be helpful to make clear that permanent and interlocutory injunctions against third-party intermediaries do not depend on the liability of the intermediary.
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here] The Commission’s and Member States’ continued efforts to push good-faith negotiations and otherwise ensure appropriate co-operation between rights owners and various types of intermediaries will be vital for developing further solutions to the complex current and future forms of on-line counterfeiting and piracy.
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here] There has been some confusion in several cases, some pending before the Court of Justice, as to whether injunctions can be issued only to prevent a specific infringer from continuing the particular infringement identified in the case. Given the speed of repeated infringements and the cost of securing repeated injunctions, it would be helpful to clarify that injunctions need not be so limited, but in appropriate cases can also cover, for example, future activities of that infringer related to the same or other titles/brands of the rights owner.
Bdwi (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Bdzv Vdz En (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Benelux Verenging Voor Merken En Modellenrecht (nl)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Beuc (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Bits Of Freedom (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Boev (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Bouygues (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Brein (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Bsa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Bskyb (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Businesseurope (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here] Any future revision of the enforcement directive should ensure coherence with the relevant provisions of the e-commerce directive including who qualifies for the liability exemptions and also with the relevant provisions of the data privacy directives.
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here] Closer cooperation between all authorities and actors involved including intermediaries is necessary.
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here] NO
Bwin Party (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Cable Europe (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Cable Europe Ecta Etno Euroispa Gsma (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ccia (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ccip (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ccip Fiche Synthese (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Cefic (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ceipi (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Cepi Fera Fiad Fiapf Ivf (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Chartered Institute Of Pa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Cmba (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Cnac (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Colipa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Comite Colbert (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Confindustria (it)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Confindustria Servizi Innovativi E Tecnologici (it)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Constant (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Consumer Focus (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Dacs (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Danish Copyright Council (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Danish Patent Agents Association (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Danske Universiteter (dk)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Dbf (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Deutsche Patentanwaltskammer (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Deutsche Patentanwaltskammer Cover (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Deutsche Post Dhl (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Deutsche Telekom (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Deutscher Anwaltverein (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Deutscher Markenverband (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Dihk (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Eaea (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ebay (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ebca (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ebf Contribution (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Eccia (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ecta (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Edima (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Edps (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Edri (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Efpia (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Egdf (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Egeda (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Egma (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Eli Lilly (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Emeca (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Enpa50 (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Epa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ericsson (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Esa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Etno (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Eurocopya (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Euroispa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
European Fashion Council (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
European Producers Club (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
European Publishers Council (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Faep (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fast
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fastweb (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fdn (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fep (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fesi (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ffii (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Finnish Commerce Federation (fi)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fimi (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fondation Giacometti (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fondation Hartung-bergman (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fondation Le Corbusier (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fox International Channels (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Fsfe (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Gema (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Gesac (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Gi Dpi (es)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Giart (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Gleiss Lutz (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Google (en)
"Google believes that there is no case for a re-opening of the Directive at this stage" (p. 10).
"The Report considers that the Directive “was not designed with the challenge posed by the Internet to the enforcement of intellectual property rights in mind”, [...] As explained earlier the IPRED provisions have been designed to balance the respective interests of right owners, users and intermediaries, including on the Internet" (p. 9-10).
- Increased liability of ISPs
"Just like in the offline environment, right owners have the primary responsibility to enforce their rights, as they are in a unique position to determine these rights and when they are effectively infringed." (p. 11).
"Voluntary measures and collaboration with IP owners undertaken by responsible ISPs to identify or prevent certain activities that may contravene applicable laws or the service’s terms of use should in no case be considered as constituting “actual knowledge” engaging the liability of ISPs" (p. 11).
"Injunctions imposed on ISPs to stop or prevent IP infringement should in no case call into question the prohibition of general monitoring obligation established in Article 15 of the e-commerce Directive and lead to an obligation for ISPs to filter their services." (p. 11).
"Making ISPs liable for any content accessed or made available through their services, would call on ISPs to systematically monitor this content. This would contradict the provisions set out in Article 15 of the e-commerce Directive, establishing that intermediaries have no general obligation to monitor the information that they transmit or store nor a general obligation to seek facts or circumstances indicating illegal activity" (p. 2).
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
"Google believes it is key for the Commission to focus on ways to facilitate copyright licensing to value content online, as opposed to additional measures on IP enforcement" (p. 5).
"[...] it is important to keep in mind that the use of content identification technologies can at best allow the identification of copyright protected content that have been identified as such by the rights holders. They cannot make the distinction between an unauthorised use of a copyright protected content, and the legitimate use of this content by users falling under the scope of a copyright exception or a license" (p. 9).
"In a technological and legal environment where a great amount of content is protected by copyright, there is no automated way to determine whether a particular use is licensed or covered by an exception to copyright law", e.g.: "Similarly, pop sensation Justin Bieber recently uploaded his own music video to YouTube, only to have it mistakenly targeted for removal by his record label" (p. 2).
"For Google’s part, we have clear policies about abuse of our services to infringe IP. We have implemented copyright notice-and-takedown provisions across our services, as well as forms to notify us of sales or advertisement of counterfeit goods through our services" (p. 3).
- Repression against further copyright infringements
"Permanent injunctions imposing general obligation to filter on intermediaries, would call into question the balance established between the interests of right owners and intermediaries, as well as the fundamental rights of the users such as the right to freedom of expression or telecommunication secrecy" (p. 8).
"[Regarding] permanent injunctions imposing general obligation to filter on intermediaries [...] while the technical feasibility or efficiency of such a monitoring is actually doubtful and contested, the use of filtering technologies entails important risks for the development of information society services. Filtering [...] risks degrading the quality and users’ experience for perfectly legitimate online services, raising serious concerns for competition and innovation".
"[...] injunctions should not be imposed that the intermediary is incapable of complying with and in particular, injunctions should not be made that breach Article 15 of the e-commerce Directive'"" (p. 9).
"[...] consider YouTube’s “Content ID”, which uses audio and video identification technology developed internally specifically for use on YouTube. This technology scans every video uploaded to YouTube and compares each with a library of more than 4 million reference files provided by participating copyright holders. If a match is identified, the system automatically applies the content owner’s instructions about what to do: whether to block the matching video from appearing on YouTube, track how users are watching it, or monetize the video by permitting advertisements to be shown alongside it." (p. 4).
Grupa Allegro (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Grur (de, en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Gsma europe (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Hai Europe (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Icc (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Icmp (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ifpi (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ifrro (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Indicam (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Inta (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Intel (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Internet Society (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Internet Society Poland Panoptykon (pl)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ip Federation (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ipo (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Isfe (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ispa Austria (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ispa Belgium (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Iuridicum Remedium (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Johan Schl�ter Advokatfirma (dk, en)
- [https://circabc.europa.eu/d/d/workspace/SpacesStore/8459d8d4-9931-4cfb-bd4c-83135f980333/johan_schl%ef%bf%bdter_advokatfirma_en.pdf johan_schl�ter_advokatfirma_en.pdf]
- [https://circabc.europa.eu/d/d/workspace/SpacesStore/1112d983-66e5-4202-8c6b-9723120805ca/johan_schl%ef%bf%bdter_advokatfirma_annexe_dk.pdf johan_schl�ter_advokatfirma_annexe_dk.pdf]
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Kepka (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Kopiosto (fi)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ksb Sas (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
La Quadrature Du Net (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
La-ex Fcforum (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Les (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Lesi (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Lyhty (fi)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Marques (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Medef (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Mediaset (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Microsoft (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Mih (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Mpa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Nuovo Imaie (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Nurpa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
ORG (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Parti Pirate (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Philips (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Pike (pl)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Pin Sme (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Pirelli (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ppl Uk (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Publishers Association (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Qdlaty (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Qxl Ricardo Denmark (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Qxl Ricardo Greece (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Rga (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Rim (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Royal Tnt Post (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Royal Tnt Post Taxud (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Saa (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sabam Form figures (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sabam Questionnaire (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sacd (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sacg (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sazas (si)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sek (fi)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sroc (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Stm (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Stop43 (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Stowarzyszenie Portal Otwartej Informacji (pl)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Sty (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Suomen Yritt�j�t (fi)
- [https://circabc.europa.eu/d/d/workspace/SpacesStore/bcd4f812-adf4-410d-86e8-72071b7bc453/suomen_yritt%ef%bf%bdj%ef%bf%bdt_fi.pdf suomen_yritt�j�t_fi.pdf]
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Swedish Publishers Association (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Tacd (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Tee (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Telecom Italia (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Telefonica (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Teva (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Tie (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Tsic (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ttvk Finnish Organisation (fi)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Tuotos (fi)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Uk Music (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Unifab (fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Union (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Upu (en, fr)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Vdma (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Ver.di (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Vit Hnilica (cz)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Vno Ncw Mkb Nederland (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Voez (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Vprt (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Vrijschrift (en)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
Vzbv (de)
- Increased liability of ISPs
[insert quote here]
- Cooperation between ISPs and rights-holders
[insert quote here]
- Repression against further copyright infringements
[insert quote here]
