IPRED2 1st reading details IE : Différence entre versions
De La Quadrature du Net
Aller à la navigationAller à la recherche| Ligne 5 : | Ligne 5 : | ||
{| border='1' cellpadding='5' cellspacing='0' class='wikitable sortable' | {| border='1' cellpadding='5' cellspacing='0' class='wikitable sortable' | ||
| − | ! MEP !! Final score !! ams. 43+44 !! am. 46/1 !! am. 46/2 !! am. 46/3 !! am. 46/4 !! am. 46/5 !! ams. 39+59/1 !! ams. 39+59/2 !! ams. 39+59/3 !! ams. 39+59/4 !! ams. 39+59/5 !! am. 38 !! ams. 50+64 !! am. 16 !! ams. 54+60 !! am. 61 !! ams. 57+62 !! amended Commission proposal !! resolution | + | ! Rank !! MEP !! Final score !! ams. 43+44 !! am. 46/1 !! am. 46/2 !! am. 46/3 !! am. 46/4 !! am. 46/5 !! ams. 39+59/1 !! ams. 39+59/2 !! ams. 39+59/3 !! ams. 39+59/4 !! ams. 39+59/5 !! am. 38 !! ams. 50+64 !! am. 16 !! ams. 54+60 !! am. 61 !! ams. 57+62 !! amended Commission proposal !! resolution |
|-id='KathySinnott' style='display:none' | |-id='KathySinnott' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[KathySinnott|Kathy SINNOTT]] || style="background:#99ff00" | 69.7 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against | + | | 142 || [[KathySinnott|Kathy SINNOTT]] {{#icon:IND.png|IND/DEM|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_IND}} || style="background:#99ff00" | 69.7 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against |
|-id='MarianHarkin' style='display:none' | |-id='MarianHarkin' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[MarianHarkin|Marian HARKIN]] || style="background:#ffe500" | 43.4 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against | + | | 260 || [[MarianHarkin|Marian HARKIN]] {{#icon:ALDE.png|ALDE|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_ALDE}} || style="background:#ffe500" | 43.4 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#008800" | abst. || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | abst. || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against |
|-id='SeanONeachtain' style='display:none' | |-id='SeanONeachtain' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[SeanONeachtain|Seán Ó NEACHTAIN]] || style="background:#ffb200" | 36.8 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against | + | | 291 || [[SeanONeachtain|Seán Ó NEACHTAIN]] {{#icon:UEN.png|UEN|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_UEN}} || style="background:#ffb200" | 36.8 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against |
|-id='LiamAylward' style='display:none' | |-id='LiamAylward' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[LiamAylward|Liam AYLWARD]] || style="background:#ffb200" | 32.9 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against | + | | 301 || [[LiamAylward|Liam AYLWARD]] {{#icon:ALDE.png|ALDE|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_ALDE}} || style="background:#ffb200" | 32.9 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against |
|-id='BrianCrowley' style='display:none' | |-id='BrianCrowley' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[BrianCrowley|Brian CROWLEY]] || style="background:#ffb200" | 32.9 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against | + | | 304 || [[BrianCrowley|Brian CROWLEY]] {{#icon:ALDE.png|ALDE|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_ALDE}} || style="background:#ffb200" | 32.9 || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against |
|-id='EoinRyan' style='display:none' | |-id='EoinRyan' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[EoinRyan|Eoin RYAN]] || style="background:#ff9900" | 27.6 || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against | + | | 346 || [[EoinRyan|Eoin RYAN]] {{#icon:UEN.png|UEN|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_UEN}} || style="background:#ff9900" | 27.6 || style="background:#dc143c" | - || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | against |
|-id='AvrilDoyle' style='display:none' | |-id='AvrilDoyle' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[AvrilDoyle|Avril DOYLE]] || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for | + | | 576 || [[AvrilDoyle|Avril DOYLE]] {{#icon:PPE.png|PPE-DE|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_PPE}} || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for |
|-id='JimHiggins' style='display:none' | |-id='JimHiggins' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[JimHiggins|Jim HIGGINS]] || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for | + | | 597 || [[JimHiggins|Jim HIGGINS]] {{#icon:PPE.png|PPE|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_PPE}} || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for |
|-id='GayMitchell' style='display:none' | |-id='GayMitchell' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[GayMitchell|Gay MITCHELL]] || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for | + | | 624 || [[GayMitchell|Gay MITCHELL]] {{#icon:PPE.png|PPE|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_PPE}} || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for |
|-id='ProinsiasdeRossa' style='display:none' | |-id='ProinsiasdeRossa' style='display:none' | ||
| − | | [[ProinsiasdeRossa|Proinsias DE ROSSA]] || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for | + | | 672 || [[ProinsiasdeRossa|Proinsias DE ROSSA]] {{#icon:SD.png|SD|11|IPRED2_1st_reading_details_SD}} || style="background:#ff4c00" | 15.8 || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#00ff00" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | against || style="background:#ff0000" | for || style="background:#ff0000" | for |
|} | |} | ||
Version du 24 septembre 2010 à 16:51
Political Memory: Criminal measures aimed at ensuring the enforcement of intellectual property rights (IPRED 2), 1st reading, Results in Detail for Ireland {{#icon:IE.png|Ireland}}
| Rank | MEP | Final score | ams. 43+44 | am. 46/1 | am. 46/2 | am. 46/3 | am. 46/4 | am. 46/5 | ams. 39+59/1 | ams. 39+59/2 | ams. 39+59/3 | ams. 39+59/4 | ams. 39+59/5 | am. 38 | ams. 50+64 | am. 16 | ams. 54+60 | am. 61 | ams. 57+62 | amended Commission proposal | resolution |
|---|
- ams. 43+44: Reject the directive - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/1: Limit to copyright and trademarks - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/2: Limit directive to commercial counterfeiting - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/3: Limit directive to commercial counterfeiting - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/4: Require malicious intent - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 46/5: Apply to legal persons - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/1: Includes unexamined, unclear IPRs (design and database rights) - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/2: Limit scope to copyright and trademarks - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/3: “Commercial scale” definition does not exclude private users (second part is explanatory, not laying down a limit). “Paying less” = “commercial advantage” - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/4: “intentional” definition is weak and unclear (replace “commercial scale” with its definition -> “obtain an economic advantage on a commercial advantage”) - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 39+59/5: Apply to legal persons - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 38: Second part only excludes imports authorised by the rights holder, which is not an infringement in the first place. Unauthorised parallel imports should be excluded, since these are not counterfeited products. - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- ams. 50+64: Excludes inciting/aiding/abetting - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 16: Protect journalists, teachers, commentators, researchers - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 54+60: Ensure C-176/03 conformance - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- am. 61: Punish abuse of this directive - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- ams. 57+62: Protect neutrality of investigation - recommendation: for, coefficient: 1
- amended Commission proposal: Proposition as amended - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
- resolution: Position of the European Parliament in first reading as stated in the previously amended proposition - recommendation: against, coefficient: 1
